We Are What We Are (2013)

We Are What We Are is a psychological horror film directed by Jim Mickle, released in 2013. A remake of the 2010 Mexican horror film of the same name, this version takes a slow-burn approach, unraveling a disturbing story of family traditions, secrecy, and survival.

Starring Bill Sage, Julia Garner, Ambyr Childers, and Kelly McGillis, the film follows the Parker family, a reclusive group bound by ancient customs that dictate their way of life. When a torrential downpour threatens to expose their dark secrets, the family must confront the consequences of their rituals—and the terrifying truth that lies beneath them.

With its haunting cinematography, unsettling atmosphere, and deeply psychological themes, We Are What We Are is a thought-provoking horror film that lingers long after the credits roll.

Plot Overview

The Parkers live in isolation, adhering to strict religious customs passed down for generations. Their lives revolve around ritual fasting, a practice that dictates their survival. However, when their matriarch suddenly dies, daughters Iris (Ambyr Childers) and Rose (Julia Garner) are forced to take on responsibilities far beyond their years.

As the town’s local doctor (Michael Parks) investigates a series of missing persons cases, he begins to suspect the Parkers. Meanwhile, the family struggles to maintain their traditions, even as guilt, fear, and external pressures threaten to unravel their world.

The film builds toward a disturbing and emotional climax, where loyalty, survival, and morality collide, forcing the Parker sisters to make an impossible choice—one that will determine the fate of their family forever.

Themes and Symbolism

🔹 Family and Tradition – The film explores how deeply ingrained customs shape identity, even when they become morally questionable. 🔹 Secrecy and Isolation – The Parkers’ secluded lifestyle reflects the danger of blind faith and unquestioned obedience. 🔹 Horror vs. Humanity – The story challenges whether monstrous acts can be justified by tradition, making viewers question who the real villains are.

Why We Are What We Are Stands Out

🔥 Atmospheric Horror – The film’s slow-burn tension and eerie cinematography create a deeply unsettling experience. 🔥 Strong Performances – Julia Garner and Ambyr Childers deliver emotionally gripping portrayals, adding depth to their characters. 🔥 Psychological Complexity – The film blends horror with emotional drama, making it more than just a typical thriller.

Reception and Legacy

Premiering at the Sundance Film Festival, We Are What We Are received positive reviews, praised for its haunting tone and thought-provoking themes. While some found its pacing slow, others appreciated its methodical storytelling and unsettling atmosphere.